Regular purchases and a lump sum
Compare cash availability before comparing returns
Two different questions
Investing newly earned income as it arrives is different from gradually investing cash already available. Only the second question compares alternative schedules for the same starting pot. A fair comparison also needs the same asset, observation period, total available cash, and treatment of uninvested cash.
When prices rise or fall
If a price rises steadily, an early lump sum buys more shares than splitting that same cash into later, more expensive purchases. If the price falls during the purchase phase, gradual buying can acquire more shares. These conditional examples explain the mechanics without deciding what an unknown market will do.
With irregular price paths, the whole sequence matters. The final share price, purchase dates, and cash remaining outside the investment all contribute to the result.
Income is not delayed cash
Money earned in a later month was not available for an earlier lump-sum purchase. Comparing a paycheck-funded plan with a full investment at the start silently assumes extra starting cash. Interest on waiting cash, transaction costs, and taxes can also change a real comparison.
Combining the two in a historical calculation
10-eok can model an amount invested at the historical start together with later recurring purchases. That starting amount is not an existing account balance imported from today. Adding it while retaining the same recurring amount increases total contributions; it does not by itself create an equal-budget test of lump sum versus gradual investment.